Start with the notice, not another nexus letter

If VA proposes to reduce an existing disability rating, first identify the reason it gives. A medical question about improvement differs from the question of what caused a condition. Buying another nexus letter may not address it.

A proposed reduction, a final decision and severance of service connection are different actions. Read the notice and promptly ask VA or an accredited representative about your response options and deadlines. Do not wait for records or a private review before checking what action is due.

Source: 38 CFR 3.105: revision procedures, reductions and hearings.

Why the earlier medical evidence matters

For ratings covered by its stabilization provisions, 38 CFR 3.344 addresses the completeness of examinations, the history of the condition and whether improvement is sustainable in ordinary life. Its applicability differs for ratings at the same level for five years or more and disabilities that have not stabilized and are likely to improve. Do not assume every protection applies to your situation.

An accredited representative can address the governing rules. A physician can address a supported medical question; a private opinion does not determine whether a reduction is legally proper.

Source: 38 CFR 3.344, including subsection (c).


Build a before-and-after evidence comparison

Keep this preparation in your own files. Use actual dates and page references; mark missing information instead of filling it in.

  1. The stated reason. Copy the notice’s explanation of the medical change. Identify which examination or findings it relies on.
  2. The earlier evidence. Locate the examination and records describing the condition when the existing rating was established or continued.
  3. The recent evidence. Identify what the newer examination measured and what it says changed. Are the same activity, symptoms and circumstances being compared?
  4. The intervening record. Include treatment response, documented improvement, remaining limitations and conflicting findings. Keep your account separate from a clinician’s findings.
  5. The unresolved medical question. State what needs explaining, not the conclusion you want the reviewer to reach.

A neutral question: “What change, if any, do the earlier and recent findings support, and what limitations remain documented during the relevant period?”

The records may be incomplete or support genuine improvement. A review should acknowledge both possibilities. Use our free printable preparation worksheet if you need space to organize your sources.


Similar concerns can lead to different answers

These fictional examples illustrate preparation, not client outcomes or medical conclusions.

Example: recent improvement, but an unanswered comparison

An earlier examination describes a limitation during a specific activity. A recent note says “improved,” but does not discuss that activity. Other dated records still describe difficulty.

Keep all three sources. Ask whether they address the same function and period, and what the missing comparison prevents a reviewer from concluding. The word “improved” alone does not tell you what every record means.

Example: improvement supported across several records

Several examinations and treatment notes consistently describe improved function. The person remains concerned about a lower rating, but has not identified contradictory medical evidence.

A paid opinion cannot manufacture contrary findings. First clarify whether there is an unresolved medical question or whether the concern is about the applicable rules. The latter belongs with VA or an accredited representative.


When a records review may be useful

A review may help explain a defined discrepancy or medical question in existing records. If the issue is an unfavorable C&P or ACE explanation, identify the exact reasoning and evidence you want considered.

Valor coordinates the client, records and appropriate physician. We do not provide in-person or video examinations, new testing, treatment or legal representation. If the question requires a new measurement, a records-only opinion may not answer it. Follow the instructions for any scheduled VA examination.

The team must confirm the requested deliverable, reviewer fit, availability, timing and terms before accepting work. An independent conclusion may be unfavorable or limited. No review guarantees restoration of a rating or a particular benefits decision.


Ask about fit before paying

Tell our case team what kind of notice you received, the general medical question and your deadline. Keep medical records and detailed history out of the general inquiry. If a review proceeds, the team provides the agreed secure records route.

Ask About a Records Review

No payment is required to ask. Contact VA or your accredited representative separately for filing instructions and deadlines.