Unfavorable C&P or ACE Opinion: What Should You Review?
Start with the medical explanation. Compare it with your records before deciding whether another review would help.
First: find the opinion and the statement you want explained.
In this guide
Use this guide to organize the medical question before commissioning an independent opinion. A second reviewer may reach the same conclusion. Check whether your review route can accept new evidence.
An ACE review can be based on existing records
VA sometimes uses the Acceptable Clinical Evidence, or ACE, process when the file contains enough medical evidence to decide the claim without an examination. Receiving a records-based opinion does not, by itself, show that the review was inadequate. Read the medical explanation and the evidence it addresses. Follow the instructions for any scheduled VA exam. VA: claim exams and ACE.
Valor coordinates a separate, privately purchased review of existing records. It does not arrange, change or replace your VA examination.
Find the medical opinion behind the decision
The decision letter and the medical opinion serve different purposes. Start with the reason stated in the decision, then locate the clinician's report or opinion that discusses the medical question. Check the date, the condition reviewed and the records referenced.
If you do not have the report, VA explains how to request the final exam report and offers a personal-records request using Form 20-10206. VA: getting your exam results · VA Form 20-10206.
A VA health-record download and a benefits claim file are different collections. Our medical records checklist explains the routes for treatment, military and claim records. Do not postpone checking a deadline while waiting for a record.
Name the part that needs explaining
You do not need to diagnose an error yourself. A short description helps the case team understand the requested review.
- A factual premise: Does the opinion describe a different date, event or medical history from the records you have?
- A missing explanation: Does it state a conclusion without explaining how the relevant findings support it?
- Competing explanations: Which possible causes does it discuss, and which records support or challenge them?
- A different medical question: Does it answer the connection being asked about? For example, whether a condition was caused by another condition is a different question from whether it was worsened by it.
A missing record, an eligibility issue and disagreement with a medical conclusion can call for different next steps. An accredited representative can help you separate the claim's legal and procedural questions from the medical evidence question.
If the opinion concerns toxic exposure, separate the exposure record, presumptive pathway and remaining medical question before deciding what additional evidence to seek.
Compare the opinion with your records
Use these prompts in your own notes. This is a preparation worksheet, not a medical opinion or a form to submit as clinical evidence.
- The statement: Copy the exact sentence and its page number. What condition, relationship or period does it address?
- The stated basis: Which findings, dates or reports does the clinician cite?
- The records to compare: Identify the document and page supporting your concern. Include records that support the clinician's explanation, too.
- The question: What needs explaining after that comparison? Keep the question open rather than supplying the conclusion you want.
- The uncertainty: What is missing or still unknown? Write “not yet known” rather than filling a gap from memory.
A useful note might read: “The opinion says no relevant symptoms were documented before 2018. A 2014 treatment note appears to describe similar symptoms. Does that note change the medical explanation, and why?” Whether the symptoms concern the same condition remains a medical question.
Keep your personal recollection separate from a documented clinical finding. Preserve the original files and context. Send medical records only through the secure records route.
Two situations that need different responses
These examples are fictional. They describe questions to clarify, not conclusions about an actual claim.
A record may change a factual premise
An opinion says the available file contains no record of a particular symptom before 2018. The veteran locates a dated 2014 treatment note that appears relevant. Later records also document a separate injury.
A focused review could ask whether the earlier note concerns the same condition and whether it changes the clinician's explanation after the later injury is considered. The earlier date does not establish service connection by itself. The independent reviewer may find it relevant, unrelated or too uncertain to change the conclusion.
Useful preparation: keep the opinion's sentence, the complete 2014 note and the later injury records together. Identify the question without omitting the contrary history.
The explanation may already address the concern
An opinion discusses the veteran's reported history, the relevant treatment records and another possible cause. The veteran disagrees with the result but cannot identify a missing record or unanswered medical question.
Buying another opinion does not guarantee a different medical judgment. Before paying, ask what additional question the review would answer. If the concern is about the review route or how evidence was handled, discuss that with an accredited representative. If new symptoms need assessment, seek appropriate clinical care; an existing-record review cannot create new examination findings.
Check the evidence route before buying a new report
Higher-Level Review cannot consider new evidence. A new medical opinion is different from an opinion already in the file. VA: Higher-Level Review.
A Supplemental Claim can consider new and relevant evidence; that does not mean every new report satisfies those requirements. VA: Supplemental Claims.
Read your decision notice and confirm the route and deadline with an accredited representative. Our HLR and Supplemental Claim comparison explains the distinction. Do not wait for an independent opinion before protecting a deadline.
What could a Valor review include?
Valor's $899 standard review covers one condition or focused medical question and one standard written opinion. A Registered Nurse and Medical Coder help prepare the records and assess readiness before physician assignment. The independent reviewer explains what the available evidence supports, including relevant limitations or conflicting findings.
A requested rebuttal, named form, addendum, multiple questions or additional reviewer may require a different agreed scope. Before paying, confirm the exact deliverable, reviewer availability, total price, timing and refund terms. A particular reviewer or specialty is not guaranteed before assessment. No extra work or charges are imposed without agreement.
The service reviews existing records. It does not include an in-person or video examination, a new diagnosis, new testing, new measurements, treatment or claims representation. No favorable medical conclusion or benefits outcome is guaranteed.
Review scope and purchase protection
Your review includes personal preparation and support through delivery. Compare the review options or ask for guidance before paying. Purchase protection covers cancellation before physician handoff, with a $50 fee. After handoff, the review is nonrefundable.
Review the standard scope · Read the purchase protection policy
Clarify the question before you choose a review
Tell us the type of opinion you have, the medical question you want addressed and any required deliverable or deadline. A free inquiry can clarify scope; it is not a clinical or records review.
Ask About My ReviewNo payment is required for a general inquiry. Keep medical records and detailed medical history out of the inquiry; use the secure Additional Intake form for all documents. See how the review process works.