Understand the medical gaps behind your denial.
We prepare the record around the reason for denial, identify what is missing, and match the medical question to an appropriate independent physician.
Start with the reason for your denial
Read the reasons in your decision before deciding what additional evidence may help. A denial can involve a medical question, a gap in the records or another eligibility issue. An independent medical opinion addresses an agreed medical question; it cannot resolve every reason for denial.
Common reasons the VA cites for denial
- No nexus established between condition and service
- VA exam (C&P) findings were unfavorable
- Condition not documented during service
- Insufficient medical evidence in the record
- Secondary service connection not supported
- Condition attributed to non-service causes
A physician can review the available records and explain whether the evidence supports the agreed medical connection. The opinion should address the relevant history, reasoning and important limitations. No favorable conclusion or VA decision is guaranteed.
What an independent medical opinion addresses
Nexus Determination
A physician reviews your records and service history to provide a clinical opinion on whether your condition is connected to your military service, using the "at least as likely as not" standard.
C&P Exam Rebuttal
An independent opinion can provide a separate medical assessment. First, review the explanation in an unfavorable C&P or ACE opinion and identify what remains unclear. A requested rebuttal needs an agreed scope; no different conclusion is guaranteed.
Structured Documentation
The written opinion is structured for VA use: it addresses diagnostic criteria, reviews the relevant evidence, and provides a clear, well-reasoned medical rationale a claims adjudicator can evaluate.
When to request an independent medical opinion
Before commissioning a new opinion, discuss the evidence gap and decision-review route with a VA-accredited representative. A new opinion may be relevant to a Supplemental Claim or an appropriate Board Appeal evidence option, depending on the rules that apply. A Higher-Level Review cannot consider new evidence. An opinion already in the record differs from one obtained after the decision. Check your decision notice and applicable deadlines.
Compare which review routes can consider a new opinion before deciding whether to buy one.
Denied without a C&P exam?
VA does not require an exam for every claim. The absence of an exam alone does not tell you whether buying a private opinion will help. Start with the reasons in your decision and the evidence VA considered.
See how a records-based opinion differs from a C&P exam. If the issue is missing private treatment records, review VA's records-gathering guidance and ask your accredited representative what is needed. A new opinion does not replace missing records or a required examination.
Source: VA Higher-Level Review evidence rules. Valor provides medical opinions, not legal representation.
A medical review may be useful when:
- Your initial claim was denied for insufficient evidence
- The decision identifies a medical question about severity or functional effects
- A C&P exam produced an unfavorable finding
- You are filing a supplemental claim with new evidence
- You are preparing for a Board of Veterans' Appeals hearing
- Secondary service connection was not established
You do not need every record before you begin
For one condition or focused medical question, the standard opinion is $899. Start with your details, then choose a review and pay or submit a request for help without payment. Your welcome email includes the separate secure records link; a case specialist helps identify what is needed. Records can follow payment.
Need a DBQ, multiple reviews or a different deliverable? Ask about scope and a custom quote before paying. No payment is required for a general inquiry. Send all documents only through the secure Additional Intake form.
Helpful records may include:
- Your VA denial letter or rating decision
- C&P exam results, if available
- Service treatment records
- Current medical records for the condition
- Prior nexus letters or medical opinions
- The condition and connection you are claiming
Use the medical records checklist for preparation and official records-request routes. Compare nexus letters, DBQs and C&P exams if you need to clarify the requested document.
Denied claims & IMOs
Still have a question? Contact us and we'll help.
Can an independent medical opinion help after a denial?
An independent medical opinion can provide a structured, physician-authored clinical assessment that addresses gaps the VA identified in your original claim. It cannot guarantee a different outcome, but it can provide objective medical documentation that may support your appeal or supplemental claim.
Which medical gaps may appear in a VA denial?
Read the reasons given in your decision. A medical question may concern a diagnosis, a connection to service or another condition, or the evidence supporting a prior opinion. A records-based opinion can address an agreed medical question; it does not resolve every reason for denial or guarantee a different decision.
Can I use an IMO to appeal an unfavorable C&P exam?
Yes. An independent medical opinion from a board-certified specialist can provide a separate, objective clinical assessment that may address weaknesses or gaps in a C&P examiner's findings. Veterans may submit independent opinions as new and relevant evidence in a supplemental claim or as supporting documentation for a Board of Veterans' Appeals hearing.
How much does an IMO cost?
The standard review is $899 for one condition or focused medical question and one records-based written opinion. Forms, multiple conditions or reviewers, and other deliverables need scope confirmation and an agreed custom quote before paying. Records can follow payment.
Does Valor guarantee my claim will be approved?
No. We provide independent medical opinions grounded in clinical documentation. The opinion's weight in your case depends on factors beyond our control, including the adjudicator's review and the totality of evidence in your file. We do not guarantee outcomes or provide medical treatment.