Which work or disability process is asking for evidence?

A long-term disability insurer, an employer and Social Security may ask different questions. An opinion written for one recipient does not automatically meet another recipient’s requirements.

For VA Individual Unemployability (TDIU), use our medical evidence and work-limitations guide. VA’s process differs from an LTD plan or a Social Security RFC assessment.

  • Employer or insurer disability benefits. Bring the benefit plan’s request, relevant instructions and any decision identifying missing medical evidence.
  • Social Security disability. Functional evidence has a specific role in SSA’s assessment. Use our Social Security and RFC guide.
  • Workplace forms, leave or return-to-work requests. Identify the exact certification or examination requested. Do not assume a records-based opinion will satisfy it.
Why the plan or program matters

The Department of Labor explains that ERISA claims rules apply to covered employee benefit plans, typically offered by private employers or unions. Government programs and government employee plans have different rules. The plan’s summary plan description is a source of information about its benefits. Do not assume every long-term disability policy is covered by ERISA.

Source: Department of Labor: benefit claims procedure FAQs, A-1 and A-2.

Ask the plan administrator or your representative about benefit definitions, submission rules and deadlines. Valor addresses the agreed medical question; we do not interpret your legal rights or decide eligibility.

If a denial relies on an insurer’s medical review, identify the statement and period you need explained. The physician’s conclusion remains independent. Review the standard scope, custom quotes and purchase protection terms before deciding.


Turn “I need a disability letter” into a defined question

Before paying for another letter, find out what remains unclear. A request may concern documented physical limitations, mental functioning, a particular period of illness or how treatment affected function.

  • What activity is at issue? Identify the work demand or functional question the recipient wants addressed.
  • Which dates matter? Include the period named in the request and records from that period where available.
  • What explanation is missing? If a decision disputes the medical evidence, bring the relevant explanation rather than asking for a predetermined conclusion.

A useful review explains what the records support and where uncertainty remains. It may identify gaps or reach a conclusion you did not hope for. A diagnosis alone does not tell the reviewer what document your recipient requires.


Map the denial to a medical question

Start with one disputed statement in the decision. Match it to the relevant dates and records before deciding whether another opinion would add useful evidence.

Work through a fictional example

Fictional example, not a client case or a recommended conclusion.

1. What the decision says
“The records do not explain why standing is limited during the period under review.” Note the decision’s page and the dates it addresses.
2. What the records show
A dated examination describes standing symptoms; a later note describes improvement. Identify both records and whether they cover the disputed period.
3. The medical question
“What, if any, standing limitations do these findings support during that period, and how does the later improvement affect that assessment?”
4. What is still unknown
The file may not establish frequency, duration or recovery time. The reviewer should explain the limit of the evidence rather than invent a number.
Use the same four prompts for your own notes
  1. Decision statement: Copy the relevant sentence, page and period.
  2. Record reference: List the document and date, including evidence that may point in a different direction.
  3. Neutral medical question: Ask what the evidence supports and why, without asking for a promised favorable answer.
  4. Unresolved gap: Identify an unavailable record, missing finding or question outside medical review. Mark uncertainty plainly.

This is a preparation aid, not a form to submit here. Keep your completed notes and medical details private; use the agreed secure route if a review proceeds.

Check whether the dispute is medical. A coverage exclusion, filing issue or disagreement about job availability may need a different response. Ask the plan administrator or your representative which issue must be addressed. A physician’s opinion does not decide policy coverage or replace a vocational assessment.

For ERISA-covered disability plans, Department of Labor guidance explains denial notices, relevant claim documents and appeal procedures. Confirm the rules and deadline for your own plan; do not wait for an opinion before protecting a deadline.

Source: Department of Labor: filing a claim for disability benefits. Not every disability policy is ERISA-covered.

Confirm the review’s scope and cost once you know the medical question.


Find the insurer’s paper or peer review in your LTD claim file

Your treatment records may not show everything the benefits administrator considered. Start with the decision notice and locate the medical explanation it relies on before buying another opinion.

Is the medical review the same as the decision notice or an examination?

An insurer’s paper or peer review may assess the medical records without examining you. Its report is different from the decision notice and from an independent medical examination (IME). When preparing a question about the review, identify which records, dates and reasoning it used rather than assuming what it says from the absence of an examination.

In your private notes, record the report’s actual title, date and page. Then map the disputed statement to a neutral medical question. If another report arrives during the appeal, use the comparison below to identify what changed. A new opinion should address the agreed question rather than assume every point needs another report.

For disability plans covered by the relevant ERISA claims rules, DOL explains that claimants can request relevant claim documents at no cost. The notice should explain the denial and identify the plan provisions involved. Ask the administrator how to obtain your relevant documents, and confirm the rules and deadline for your plan with the administrator or your representative. Not every disability policy is ERISA-covered. DOL: Filing a Claim for Your Disability Benefits.

Do not wait for records or an opinion before checking your deadline.

Make a short inventory of the file

Keep these notes with your own records. For each item, mark available, requested or not yet known, and record its date or page where useful.

  • The request: Recipient, exact document or form, disputed period and deadline.
  • The decision: The statement you want explained and the plan provision it refers to.
  • The medical explanation: The reviewer's report or other rationale identified in the decision.
  • The clinical evidence: Relevant treatment notes, tests and assessments from the period in question, including findings that differ from your account.
  • The work information: The duties or job information supplied by the recipient, if relevant to the medical question. Note the exact plan wording and period, including any “own occupation” or “any occupation” terms; ask the administrator or your representative which definition applies.
  • The unresolved question: What could a clinician explain from existing records, and what would need missing records, a new examination, legal interpretation or vocational expertise?

Fictional example: A decision refers to a medical review dated June 12, but the claimant's folder contains only the decision and treatment notes. Mark the June 12 review “requested.” Until it is available, do not assume what its reasoning says. A new opinion can be scoped more clearly once the actual medical question is identified.

A physician can explain supported medical limitations; the plan administrator or your representative can clarify the plan’s requirements. Questions about job availability or vocational fit may need vocational expertise. For example, a medical question about hand function while typing differs from whether alternative jobs exist.

A missing document differs from a missing clinical finding. A records-based review can explain existing evidence; it cannot produce a new lifting test or examination result. Keep appointments required by your program.

A new medical review arrived during the appeal

Compare the new report with the original explanation before requesting more physician work. For disability appeals covered by the relevant ERISA rules, new or additional evidence or a new rationale must be provided without charge sufficiently before the adverse appeal decision to allow a reasonable response. Confirm applicability, the recipient and your response deadline with the plan administrator or your representative; do not assume a deadline is paused while you obtain an opinion.

Source: 29 CFR 2560.503-1(h)(4): disability appeal evidence and rationale.

In your private notes, keep the report date and page beside:

  • What changed: The previous statement and the new statement, including the period each addresses.
  • Why it changed: A newly supplied record, a different interpretation of existing evidence, or a repeated explanation. Mark what you cannot yet tell.
  • What needs explaining: Supporting and contrary record citations, the unanswered clinical question, and any missing document or finding.

Fictional contrast: A new review relies on a later note describing improvement. Ask whether that note changes the assessment for the earlier disputed period and why. If the report instead repeats that standing limitations are unexplained, identify whether any relevant evidence or question has changed. A new report date alone does not establish a new medical issue.

These notes are a preparation aid, not an appeal submission template. Additional physician work may need a different agreed scope. Confirm the changed question, deliverable, price, reviewer availability and timing before proceeding.

Social Security approved benefits, but the LTD plan disagrees

An SSDI award does not automatically decide an LTD claim. For disability plans covered by the relevant ERISA claims rules, an adverse notice must explain its basis for disagreeing with an SSA disability determination you presented to the plan. Confirm applicability with the administrator or your representative.

Keep the SSA determination, its supporting medical evidence and the LTD explanation separate. Compare dates, supported restrictions and the stated disagreement. Then identify the remaining medical question; policy or vocational issues may need a different response. Another physician opinion does not decide coverage.

Source: 29 CFR 2560.503-1(g)(1)(vii)(A) and (j)(6)(i): disability decision explanations.

Not sure whether your request needs a standard written opinion or a different deliverable? Ask a free scope question. Include the document's title, intended recipient and deadline. Keep medical records and detailed health information out of the inquiry; use the secure Additional Intake form for all documents. Scope, reviewer availability, price and terms need confirmation before paying for custom work. No favorable conclusion or benefit outcome is guaranteed.


LTD payments stopped after approval: what changed?

A termination after a period of payment is different from an initial denial. Start with the notice’s actual reason. A prior approval does not by itself establish that current medical evidence satisfies the plan’s requirements.

Protect the next action first. Ask the administrator or your representative about the applicable response process and deadline. Do not wait for a private report before checking what is due. Not every disability policy is governed by ERISA, and a fixed benefit period ending is not the same issue as a disputed medical finding.

Separate a medical change from a change in the policy test
  • The insurer says your condition or function improved. Locate the earlier approval’s medical basis, the current medical review and records covering the intervening period. Compare the same activity and findings, including documented improvement and continuing restrictions.
  • The occupation definition changed. Keep the actual clause, transition date and work-demand or vocational report. “Own occupation” and “any occupation” can ask different questions under the policy even if your medical condition is unchanged. A physician can explain supported restrictions; legal interpretation and job availability need different expertise.
  • The reason is missing information, a benefit limit or another nonmedical issue. Identify what the administrator actually requests. Another medical opinion may not solve a missing treating-clinician form or a policy-only dispute.

For illustration, one Standard group LTD certificate has distinct own- and any-occupation definitions and provisions about when benefits end. It is an example, not your policy or a rule for all insurers. Use your actual plan, amendments and notice.

Prepare an approval-to-termination evidence comparison
  1. Earlier basis: approval or continuation notice, relevant period and the medical findings it relied on. Mark unavailable reasoning as unknown.
  2. Current reason: exact statement in the termination notice and the medical review, policy provision or other source it identifies.
  3. Evidence in between: dated findings about the same activity, treatment response, remaining limitations and contrary evidence.
  4. The question: what medical change or continuing restriction needs explaining for the period at issue? Keep policy interpretation and vocational conclusions separate.

Fictional contrast: An older approval describes limited standing. A later report says treatment improved symptoms but does not address standing. That may leave a medical comparison to clarify. If the notice instead applies a different occupation definition, an unchanged diagnosis alone does not resolve that issue. Neither example establishes an insurer error or a favorable medical conclusion.

Use the existing preparation worksheet for your private notes. Then define the remaining medical question. A new opinion should have an agreed purpose, not simply repeat the earlier report.

For covered plans, 29 CFR 2560.503-1 addresses adverse decisions and review procedures. Confirm applicability and your next action with the administrator or your representative.

If the question is medical and existing records can address it, confirm the written-opinion scope and terms before paying. A records review does not replace an examination, treating-clinician certification or vocational assessment, and does not guarantee restored payments. For Social Security benefits, use the separate adult medical CDR evidence guide; the same policy test does not apply.


What records help the team assess your request?

You can first ask about fit without sending medical records. Describe the requested deliverable and intended use. If the review proceeds, use the secure Additional Intake form for documents.

A practical preparation checklist
  • The actual request. Include instructions, the requested form and any relevant decision or medical explanation.
  • Relevant clinical evidence. Treatment notes, testing, prior evaluations and documented treatment response may help answer the agreed question.
  • Work information supplied by the recipient. A job description or stated duties can provide context when the question concerns particular activities.
  • A factual timeline and missing-record list. Separate your recollections from clinical findings. Preserve records that may differ from your account.

You do not need every possible record. Tell the case team what exists and what is missing; do not fill gaps by guessing. See our medical records checklist.


Is an Attending Physician Statement the same as an independent opinion?

No. An insurer’s Attending Physician Statement (APS) and an independent records-based opinion can serve different purposes. Confirm the exact form and who the recipient will accept as its signer before paying for a review. Valor’s $899 standard written opinion does not automatically include an APS.

What to check when your insurer requests an APS

For example, The Standard’s LTD form asks about treatment dates, the most recent visit, planned treatment and functional limitations. That is one insurer’s form, not a universal rule for every policy.

  • Identify the missing item: a treatment update, an unanswered form question, a new examination or an explanation of existing evidence.
  • Confirm the signer requirements: an independent reviewer does not become your treating physician by reviewing records.
  • Agree the deliverable: A records-based opinion does not replace a required treating-clinician certification. Requested forms need scope and reviewer confirmation.

Example: The Standard’s Attending Physician Statement (June 2025).

Ask about the requested document with its title, recipient and deadline. No payment is required to ask; use the secure Additional Intake form for all documents. Confirm availability, price and timing before proceeding.


Is a records-based opinion the service you need?

Valor’s standard service reviews existing records and provides one written physician opinion. It does not include an in-person or video examination, new diagnosis, treatment or an automatic certification of fitness for work.

If your notice requires an independent medical examination, a functional capacity evaluation or a treating clinician’s certification, confirm the requirement with the recipient. A written records review is a different deliverable. Keep appointments arranged by your program; purchasing an opinion does not cancel or replace them.


Connect a work demand to the medical evidence

Start with the work or occupation document supplied by the recipient. In private notes, record the demand and source page, the clinical record addressing it, and the remaining medical question. Our preparation worksheet has space for this comparison.

A fictional example

The recipient describes repeated keyboard use. An examination records hand symptoms; a later note reports improvement. The question is which restrictions, if any, those findings support during the relevant period, and what remains unknown. Do not fill in unsupported time limits or work-capacity numbers.

Ask the administrator or representative about the applicable policy and occupation requirements. A records-based medical opinion does not determine job availability or replace a vocational assessment or new examination.

Organize your request before asking about scope

Our free printable preparation worksheet helps you identify the requested document, relevant period, evidence you have and remaining questions. Keep completed notes private and use the agreed secure route for medical records.


What does a work or disability review cost?

The $899 standard review covers one condition or focused medical question and one written physician opinion, with personal records preparation and support through delivery. Records can follow payment when this scope fits.

For a records-based physical or mental assessment, compare the $1,499 Physical or Mental RFC Review. No examination or new measurements are included. Combined assessments, forms outside the selected scope, multiple questions or additional reviewers need a custom quote.

Other specialized deliverables are not automatically included. Ask us to confirm availability, scope, price and refund terms before paying. A custom quote states its agreed terms; extra work or charges require agreement.

Your review includes personal preparation and support through delivery. Compare the review options or ask for guidance before paying. Purchase protection covers cancellation before physician handoff, with a $50 fee. After handoff, the review is nonrefundable.


Choose your next step

One focused written opinion

If the standard scope fits, begin the $899 review. Secure records follow afterward. Requested forms and treating-clinician certifications are not included.

Start Your Review

A physical or mental assessment

Compare the $1,499 Physical or Mental RFC Review: one physical assessment by a physician OR one mental assessment by a licensed clinical psychologist. No exam or new measurements.

See RFC Scope & Purchase

Need a specific form, combined assessment or help choosing? Ask a free scope question.

Start with your details. Choose a review and pay, or submit a request for help without payment. No payment is required to ask. Confirm timing before relying on a delivery date. Use the secure Additional Intake form for all documents.